University of Florida Homepage

Aristarchus’ Derivation of the Sun’s Distance

Aristarchus’ seventh proposition is his most important, since there the essential numerical result is derived. The demonstration is reproduced here in brief. In the figure below, A represents the position of the sun, B the earth, C the moon when seen halved. Hence angle EBD = angle BAC = 3 degrees. Let the angle FBE (=45 degrees) be bisected by BG. Since the ratio of a great and a small tangent to a circle is greater than the ratio od the underlying arcs and angles, the ratio GE and HE will be greater than the ratio of 1/4 to 1/30 of a right angle, that is, greater than 15/2.

Further, FG:GE = BF:BE = the square root of 2, greater than 7/5; hence FE/GE is greater than 12/5. Combining it with the first inequality, we find the ratio of FE to HE greater than 15/2 x 12/5 = 18; and the ratio AB/BC which is equal to BH/HE, hence a little larger than BE/HE is certainly also greater than 18.

Applying, on the other hand, the proposition that the ratio of a great and a small chord is smaller than the ratio of the subtended arcs, upon DE subtending 6 degrees in the half-circle BDE, and the side of a regular hexagon, equal to the radius, subtending and arc of 60 degrees, we find the ratio of 1/2 BE to DE smaller than 10, hence the ratio of AB to BC smaller than 20.